Discontinuity

Hot crack (solidification cracking)

A crack that forms while the weld is still partly liquid, when low-melting films between growing grains are pulled apart by shrinkage before the metal has any strength to resist it.

Original illustration — indicative of the appearance, not to any particular scale.

What it looks like

  • Often visible immediately after welding, sometimes opening while the bead is still glowing
  • Follows the grain boundaries, giving an irregular, branching path rather than a straight split
  • Fracture faces show a rounded, oxidised, dendritic surface rather than the bright faces of a cold crack
  • Commonly runs along the bead centreline where opposing grain fronts meet

Causes

  • Sulphur, phosphorus, and other low-melting elements picked up from the base metal, forming weak liquid films
  • A deep narrow bead shape that drives columnar grains to meet head-on at the centreline
  • High restraint pulling on the joint during the brief mushy stage between liquid and solid
  • Fully austenitic stainless deposits with no ferrite to interrupt the continuous liquid film
  • Excessive travel speed producing a tear-drop shaped puddle that concentrates segregation at the centre

Prevention

  • Choose filler metal that deposits a small amount of ferrite when welding austenitic stainless steel
  • Keep bead width equal to or greater than depth so grains do not meet on a single weak plane
  • Limit dilution from base metals high in sulphur or phosphorus by controlling penetration
  • Reduce travel speed to give a more elliptical puddle and a less segregated centreline

How it is found

VT
Solidification cracks appear immediately, so a welder or inspector watching the bead cool often sees the crack open on its own.
PT
The branching surface crack draws penetrant readily and bleeds into developer as a distinctly irregular indication.
MT
On carbon steel deposits the surface-breaking crack leaks the applied field and holds particles along its jagged path.

How inspectors think about it

  • The branching, grain-boundary path of a hot crack tells an inspector the cause was metallurgical rather than mechanical, which changes the corrective action entirely.
  • As a crack it is treated as a rejectable planar flaw regardless of length, and it rarely occurs in isolation once conditions favour it.
  • Repair alone seldom solves the problem, because rewelding with the same consumable into the same chemistry reproduces the liquid films that cracked the first time.

General reasoning only. The accept/reject limits for your work come from the code or specification governing the job, which this site does not reproduce.

Related discontinuities

Can you name it on sight?

The gauge trainer's identification mode shows you a weld and four names. Reading about porosity and picking it out of a line-up are not the same skill.

Open the gauge trainer